How Do You Identify Vendor Compliance Gaps?
Vendor compliance gaps are most reliably caught through a structured trust-but-verify review of active vendor relationships, not by waiting for a regulator or incident to surface them. For organizations that have grown quickly or inherited vendor portfolios through acquisitions, the exposure is often larger than it appears. Joy at The Joyous Edge works with C-suite executives and their leadership teams to make that exposure visible and manageable: "We simplify the process, reduce the risk, and multiply the revenue for C-suite executives and their leadership teams."
The starting point is straightforward: map every active vendor against the organization's current regulatory obligations. If the vendor's risk profile has never been mapped to the organization's North Star for compliance, the gap is likely larger than it appears.
Where Do Vendor Compliance Gaps Actually Come From?
Gaps do not usually start with a bad vendor. They start with a relationship that was reviewed once, at the beginning, and never revisited as the business changed around it.
The most common sources:
Scope creep without contract review. A vendor brought in for one function quietly absorbs two or three more. The original due diligence covered the original scope. Nobody re-ran it.
Regulatory change without vendor notification. New rules take effect. Internal teams update their own policies. The vendor is not told, and their practices drift out of alignment.
Inherited vendors from acquisitions or leadership changes. A predecessor approved the relationship. The current team inherited it with no independent review of what it actually covers or what risk it now carries.
Data access that was never formally scoped. The vendor has access to customer data, transaction records, or sensitive systems that was granted informally and never documented in the contract.
Absent or outdated monitoring. The FDIC notes that an effective third-party risk compliance management process includes ongoing monitoring as one of its four main elements alongside risk assessment, due diligence, and contract structuring and review. When monitoring stops, gaps accumulate silently.
No clear owner internally. Vendor relationships that span legal, operations, and compliance with no single accountable owner tend to fall through the cracks of all three.
Each of these is a structural problem, not a performance problem. The vendor may be doing exactly what they were asked to do. The gap is in what was asked.
How Do You Run a Trust-But-Verify Review of Vendor Relationships?
A trust-but-verify review does not assume the worst about a vendor. It assumes that time passes, scope shifts, and regulations change - and that a relationship approved at any point deserves a fresh look against today's obligations.
Nancy Mercurio, Executive Coach and Organizational Development Specialist, and a Board Member for One Unlimited Inc., has observed this kind of work directly: "Joy is bright, talented, a hard worker, and a contributor. As a Board Member for One Unlimited Inc., I've had the privilege of watching her career unfold. She brings value to the organization and reaches beyond the job to uncover issues and provide guidance. Aside from her skill set, she is a wonderful human being. It is a pleasure to know her and to make this recommendation on her behalf." That quality of reaching beyond the surface to uncover issues is exactly what a trust-but-verify review demands. Joy brings 25+ years of experience in governance, risk, and compliance to this work, including a former Managing Director role at KPMG and senior roles at HSBC, E*TRADE, and Sallie Mae, and has helped build multiple AI, data, and risk governance programs and frameworks.
The Federal Reserve's guidance on third-party risk management states that due diligence should assess a third party's ability to perform as expected, adhere to the organization's policies, comply with applicable laws and regulations, and conduct the activity in a safe and sound manner. That standard applies not just at onboarding but throughout the life of the relationship.
A practical review works through four questions for each active vendor:
1. What is this vendor actually doing today, compared to what the contract says? Pull the current contract and compare it to actual activity. If the scope has expanded, the risk assessment needs to expand with it.
2. What regulatory obligations apply to this vendor relationship right now? Not at signing - now. Identify every applicable regulation, internal policy, and client contractual requirement that touches what this vendor does.
3. What controls does the vendor have in place, and have they been verified? FINRA has observed recurring examination issues including not conducting ongoing due diligence on third-party providers and not validating data protection controls in third-party provider contracts. Asking for a SOC report or attesting that controls exist is not the same as verifying them.
4. Who internally owns this relationship, and when was it last reviewed? If the answer to either part is unclear, that is itself a finding.
For organizations managing AI and vendor risk proactively, this same framework applies - the technology layer does not change the underlying structure of what a compliant vendor relationship requires.
What Does a Compliance Gap Look Like When You Find One?
Compliance gaps in vendor relationships tend to surface in one of three forms.
The first is a documentation gap: the vendor is performing adequately, but there is no evidence trail that would satisfy a regulator. Contracts are unsigned or outdated. Audit rights exist on paper but have never been exercised. Certifications have lapsed.
The second is a control gap: the vendor's actual practices do not meet the standard the organization's policies require. This is the most operationally serious form, because it means the risk is live, not just undocumented.
The third is a scope gap: the vendor is doing work that was never formally assessed for compliance risk. This often happens in fast-growing organizations where vendor relationships are added quickly and reviewed later - except "later" never comes.
Amanda Holt, Executive Director, described the approach that closes these gaps well: "Joy is a skilled, detail-oriented team player who understands the importance of thorough review. She consistently makes pertinent recommendations that serve to protect the interests of the organization." That observation captures the discipline a vendor compliance review requires - not a surface-level check, but a thorough one that actually protects the organization.
What Should You Do When You Find a Vendor Compliance Gap?
Finding a gap is not a crisis. Leaving it unaddressed is. The Interagency Guidance on Third-Party Relationships is clear that organizations should monitor a third party's compliance with applicable laws, regulations, and contractual provisions, and require remediation of compliance issues that arise.
Remediation follows a straightforward sequence. First, document the gap precisely - what is missing, what the standard requires, and what the current state actually is. Second, determine whether the gap is a documentation problem, a control problem, or a scope problem, because each requires a different fix. Third, assign an internal owner and a vendor contact with a defined timeline for resolution. Fourth, build the monitoring cadence that prevents the same gap from reopening.
The goal is not to punish a vendor. The goal is to close the exposure and create a record that demonstrates the organization identified the issue and acted on it. That record matters to regulators, to boards, and to clients who have their own vendor oversight requirements.
For organizations that want to understand the full picture of what a structured review covers, The Joyous Edge Vendor & Third-Party Risk Review Guide walks through the assessment framework in plain terms executives can act on.
A vendor compliance review is one of the clearest places where that work pays off - because the exposure is already there, and the cost of finding it on your terms is always lower than finding it on a regulator's.
If your vendor relationships have grown faster than your reviews of them, that conversation is worth having now. Reach out at contact@thejoyousedge.com, visit https://thejoyousedge.com, or Book a call with me at: freejoycall.com.
FAQ
Who is responsible for identifying vendor compliance gaps inside an organization? Ownership typically sits at the intersection of compliance, legal, and the business unit that manages the vendor relationship day to day. In practice, gaps persist most often when no single person has clear accountability. Assigning an internal owner for each material vendor relationship - someone who monitors performance, tracks regulatory changes, and triggers periodic reviews - is the structural fix that prevents gaps from accumulating undetected.
Which vendors pose the highest compliance risk and should be reviewed first? Priority belongs to vendors with access to sensitive customer data, vendors performing regulated activities on behalf of the organization, and vendors whose failure would directly affect the organization's ability to meet its regulatory obligations. Inherited vendors from acquisitions or leadership transitions also warrant early review, because they often carry assumptions about prior due diligence that have never been independently verified.
How often should vendor compliance reviews be conducted? Review frequency should be driven by the vendor's risk tier, not by a fixed calendar. High-risk vendors - those with data access, regulatory exposure, or critical operational roles - warrant annual review at minimum, with event-triggered reviews whenever scope changes, regulations shift, or a significant incident occurs. Lower-risk vendors can be reviewed on a longer cycle, provided there is a mechanism to escalate them when circumstances change.
What does a regulator expect to see when examining vendor compliance oversight? Regulators expect documented evidence of the full lifecycle: initial risk assessment, due diligence at onboarding, a contract that specifies compliance obligations and audit rights, and ongoing monitoring with a record of findings and remediation. The Federal Reserve's guidance specifies that third-party risk management should assess a vendor's ability to comply with applicable laws and regulations throughout the relationship - not only at the point of selection.




Comments